More Special Reports

Professor Yves A Isidor conveys his thoughts or opinion to the U.S. news media (partial)

Search for:

Haiti Since the January 12th, 2010 Fierce Earthquake
or a Year that Began with Goudou-goudou
All related links below                                          
Post-Eartquake Haiti
The year of surviving in squalor
Even allowing for some unique difficulties, the effort of the government and
outsiders to rebuild have been disappointing

JANUARY 1st was the 207th anniversary of the day that Haiti became the second country in the Americas to declare independence. To mark their achievement of an equivocal freedom, Haitians traditionally eat pumpkin soup. This year some did not bother. “None of us felt like celebrating,” said Micheline Michel, whose home is a shanty of bed sheets opposite the ruins of the National Palace. Instead, she spent the holiday hawking old clothes around the concrete carcasses of buildings that litter the city centre.

Around 1m Haitians have been living like Ms Michel in tents or under tarpaulins since January 12th last year, when Port-au-Prince was devastated by a huge earthquake officially estimated to have killed 230,000 people. A year that began with goudou-goudou, the onomatopoeic neologism Haitians use to refer to the quake, ended with cholera on a death march across the country, a sometimes violent electoral dispute and a palpable vacuum of leadership.

When she and her family sought refuge in their shelter last January, Ms Michel believed they would stay for a couple of weeks or maybe a month. “I never imagined that a year later, we’d still be living in such absolute misery,” she says. Few did.

But when visiting journalists parachute in to Port-au-Prince for the anniversary of the earthquake, they will see few signs of progress and many of stasis. Rubble still blocks many streets. Even if the work of removing it goes according to the official schedule, less than half will be cleared by October. Only about 30,000 temporary shelters have been built. The National Palace, the emblem of Haitian sovereignty, has yet to be demolished, let alone rebuilt. The tent camps that dot the city look ever-shabbier, and their inhabitants thinner and more bedraggled.

This landscape of neglect and degradation mocks the widespread hope in the weeks after the quake that Haiti could “build back better,” as Bill Clinton, the United Nations special envoy to the country, put it. The government’s promising reconstruction plan, unveiled at a donor conference in March, envisioned moving many people outside the swollen capital and injecting economic life into rural areas, as well as rebuilding Port-au-Prince.

Little of this has happened. The only official relocation site is a barren wasteland on the outskirts of the capital which shelters fewer than 10,000 people, many of whom feel they were tricked into moving there. Donors pledged $5.8 billion for recovery and reconstruction until September 2011. But less than half of that has been disbursed, and a big chunk has gone on debt relief rather than fresh funds.

The Interim Haiti Reconstruction Commission (IHRC), with an equal number of Haitian and international members, was supposed to act as a powerful, open and accountable executive agency. But it has met rarely, its mandate expires in nine months, and at its fourth meeting in December the 12 Haitian members complained in a letter that they felt left out. Haiti remains a “republic of NGOs”, as officials put it, some of which are doing vital relief work and others just getting in the way.

Some of the frustration stems from unrealistic expectations. Pamela Cox, a World Bank official who sits on the IHRC, points out that even rich, functioning states have struggled after catastrophes, as the United States did after Hurricane Katrina. Although she concedes that planning for reconstruction should have started earlier, Ms Cox says she sees progress: 400,000 houses have been assessed and classified by structural engineers, debris removal is accelerating and the economy has held up.

State institutions were already weak and dysfunctional in Haiti before the earthquake knocked out the capital. René Préval, the president, was in the last year of his mandate. Even so, many Haitians believe that his government demonstrated little will or concern for its people, or ability to meet even minimal expectations. However, the ruling party sprang into life when the campaign for a general election kicked off in October. It spent ostentatiously on the campaign.

Distracting though the election might have seemed, Haitians need a legitimate government to deal with the political issues at the heart of rebuilding, including land tenure, property rights and spending priorities. Investors and donors similarly need a legitimate government to ensure that their funds are not wasted.

But the election on November 28th became another setback. Hundreds of thousands of Haitians did not receive voting cards; around 4% of polling stations were trashed; and the Organisation of American States (OAS) withdrew its observers in mid-afternoon, leaving the count unsupervised. The official result declared a run-off between Mr Préval’s unpopular candidate, Jude Célestin, and Mirlande Manigat, a constitutional lawyer, excluding Michel Martelly, a popular musician. That ignited several days of sometimes violent anti-government protests.

The OAS is overseeing a thorough recount of the tally sheets. The run-off scheduled for January 16th has been postponed until at least February. The recount is a practical necessity but has no basis in electoral law. Perhaps the miracle of an effective and legitimate government will yet emerge. But it may be that outsiders’ biggest mistake last year was not taking more trouble to ensure that the election went better than reconstruction.

Related Links


Haiti's radioactive president says "A Haitian army, not exactly what I want to see in Haiti"

Untold numbers of flaws have been found in controversial U.S. report estimating death toll from Haiti's fierce  earthquake last year

U.S. Department of State is reluctant to endorse what appears to be a fictive or misguided report on Haiti's January 12, 2010 fierce earthquake

U.S. A. I. D backs away from report most incendiary figure, an estimated quake death toll of 46,000 to 85,000 people

Haiti's profound sorrow for decades to come

Natural disasters losses in 2010, astronomical

Born of 9 11, an effort to rebuild shattered Haiti

SLIDESHOW/Haiti: The Shattered Year

ALSO, LISTEN/A Year Of Challenges: Haiti After The Quake

A year later, Haiti struggles back

A few Haitian-Americans, the vagabond people who call African-Americans "Social Deviants"

Less than 2 percent of billions pledged for Haiti has been disbursed

Eligible Haitian nationals have until Jan. 18, 2011 to apply for Temporary Protected Status (TPS)

video, shocking

LISTENN/ Haiti, six months since the earthquake

Haitian orphans have little but one another

videoShe does not want to be used as a Restavek - a child servant

A parish tested - A bond in devotion to Haiti is left shattered

AUDIO SLIDE SHOW/Displaced see their stories on TV

videoHorrifying: New video shows Haiti national palace collapsing

Signs of cover-up after killings in Haiti prison

Panel on Haitian prison deaths

EDITORIAL/Slaughter in les Cayes

Stoppable, Haiti Preval to jam more radio stations, also assassinate earthquake surviving journalists
U.N. launches long-awaited website to track Haiti aid

SLIDESHOW/OPINION/Haiti, three months later

At least one dead in Haiti house collapse

Earthquake in Haiti: "Deronette Brothers," a cancer in the body of Jesus of Nazareth

Wilson Deronette responds to accusations that uses God's name to practize corruption

Quake survivors freed from immigration jails

Haiti's founding document found in London

videoUnited Nations: International Donors Conference Towards a New Future for Haiti

AUDIO SLIDESHOW/Haiti: The quality of life of the poor, the quality of life of the irresponsible rich

In Haiti, after a handshake Bush washes hand on Clinton's shirt

Earthquake in Haiti: Boston's "Deronette Brothers" on the accused bench

IMAGES/Former U.S. Presidents George W.  Bush, Bill Clinton visit earthquake ravaged-Haiti capital city of Port-au-Prince

Earthquake in Haiti: In Boston, wild birds are raising money, and fast

videoPres. Obama and Pres. Rene Preval Joint press Conference

videoHaiti's curse of generalized corruption

Obama tells Haitian leader that U.S. aid will continue

videoSinging the suffering of Haiti

Haiti, then Chile: What can be learned from both fierce earthquakes?

After the fierce earthquake, Haiti needs economics, institutions, and development

Haiti fierce earthquake: A photo gallery

The January 12 earthquake: Report on damage

Lost limbs redefine life for thousands in Haiti

Panoramas: Views from Haiti

Why did so many people die in Haiti Earthquake?

Haiti earthquake: A photo gallery    


NOTE: This page, to be updated on a continuing basis.                                        , the scholarly journal of democracy and human rights
More from
Main / Columns / Books And Arts / Miscellaneous